» Yoga Blog

Home > Kreg Weiss, My Yoga Online, Yoga, Yoga Anatomy > When a Yoga Workout Goes Wrong

When a Yoga Workout Goes Wrong

I was recently asked about my opinion about ‘fatigue’ and reaching to one’s physical limits in yoga practices. I had presented my earlier opinion that excessive fatigue should be avoided in a yoga class. As teachers, we should apply this principle and as students, we need to observe this mindfully. I realized that my definition of ‘excessive fatigue’ was not well presented as I was challenged on the idea that working the body to a place of fatigue is actually beneficial. I, therefore, decided to redefine my philosophy on fatigue in this blog post.

Yoga FatigueThe body is highly adaptable to the stressors or lack of stressors presented to it. Without conditioning and challenge, the body weakens and looses vitality. Regardless of the type of physical activity, we should present the musculoskeletal and circulatory with progressive overload conditioning. This means we should bring the body’s systems to an elevated state of conditioning that is very near maximal output in a variety of conditions. This overload principle acts as a stressor telling the body to adapt, to improve, to be able to accommodate this physical loading in the future - this is represented in many ways:

*increased muscle density if challenging strength
*improved alveolar capacity and oxygen uptake in the lungs if challenging the cardiovascular system
*improved elasticity of tendons and muscle fibers if challenging flexibility

Change will not occur without mindfully challenging the systems. However, it is often mistaken that deep, excessive fatigue is the representation of proper stressors in progessive overload. The problem with coming into a place of deep fatigue is the high potential for injury. Take Warrior 1 Yoga pose as an example. If you hold, and hold, and hold the pose, the quadriceps will develop lactic acid and the muscle fibers loose the capacity to generate contractile force (lactic acid prevents the reformation of ATP - the energy component crucial for muscle contraction). Therefore, the next series of tissues that need to takeover are the quadricep tendons. If the pose is already positioned very deep, the strain moving into the tendons can be highly stressful. Combine this with repetitive stress of other activities (like skiing or jogging), there is strong potential for acute or chronic tissue damage.

Another example: I see so many yoga students attempting full chaturanga (pushup transition to the ground) while ignoring their fatigue level and strength capacity. With deep fatigue setting into the triceps and shoulders, we often see the elbows fall outwards (as the body is struggling to shift the force load into the chest muscles). We also see the collapse of energy being transmitted into the shoulder girdle and core. Where is the functionality in this? Is it worth it to have excessive fatigue while placing harm to the wrists, shoulders, and spine? All for strong or sexy arms? All to appease the Ego?

Yoga WorkoutSo I present this thought to Yoga Teachers and students who wish to approach their yoga practice as a ‘workout’, do you wish to have a long term practice? Does a body free of injury have getter priorty than accomplishment? When you bring your students or yourself to the edge of strength or endurance, pull your inner gaze in with full defined focus and see what the rest of the body is doing-is everything in check? Is the integrity and function still intact? If not, modify, rest, or change the state of the pose.

Consider as well the energetic quality. For anyone using their yoga practice as a workout, go watch a yoga video of David Svenson. The level of his practice is outstanding, but with such grace and control. You do not see fatigue in the body, the eyes or in his breath. Complete essence of integrity. Getting to this level of practice does not come from pushing the body to extreme fatigue and with Ego.

As a side note, we are wonderfully inspired by athletes, the Olympics, and other sporting events. We often become inspired to become ‘fit’ and view these athletes as role models. Keep in mind, almost every single high level athlete endures some form of major injury in their career. And this is a ‘career’. They eventually retire from the sport and many retire with chronic injuries plaguing them for the rest of their lives. Do we need to treat our yoga practice as a sport, as a competition, as something we will need to retire from eventually? Whether you are in the gym, out for a run, or in the Yoga studio, ask yourself why I am doing this? To feel good? What is it that is making you ‘feel good’-the health benefits or the accomplishment of physicality? What if a sudden deep injury eliminated all those accomplishments? Would you still ‘feel good’ within yourself?

Fatigue in Yoga and exercise is beneficial and is good, but when done with the right intention and application. As Yoga Teachers, we should offer practices that our students NEED and not WANT. Health is often one of the most undervalued assets when we have it. Remember this when you move deep into a physical practice. Breathe in humility. Exhale out the Ego. Understand where your desire for accomplishment in physicality stems from. Be your practice with grace.

Namaste,
Kreg Weiss
My Yoga Online

Kreg Weiss Kreg Weiss, My Yoga Online, Yoga, Yoga Anatomy , , , , , ,

  1. Tina
    October 24th, 2009 at 14:52 | #1

    The TWENTY-FOUR YEAR OLD, bendy size 2, nothing wrong with her, yoga studio instructor/owner is frequently pulling some muscle and sometimes gets so out of commission that she can’t teach her classes. This is great advertising for the style they teach at the studio–NOT. But I digress, I find that this particular yoga studio teaches their classes in a rather high gear.

    They are resorting to drastic price-drops for the introductory first month to get new students in the door. (Of course that at first pi$$ed me off–actually, later I felt flattered, after a fashion: I was not SO late an adopter that it took anything other than one free intro class (taught with deceptive sukha however) to lure me in.

    My second class, my body became their battlefield, and I’d really let them have it! They’d had no business substituting the real classes for the fake ones. Later I found out that it’s more than one instructor’s personality or methodology to do so.

    The studio did their job splendidly when I learned from them to kick my own butt at home. I do not attend class frequently. I do not intend to renew with them. I do hour-long sessions at home.

    If I find I need the “feeling of socialization”, there is a gym a little further down the road (also has yoga classes–probably mild ones) that I could go to as many times as I like for about the same as the price per month of the introductory membership at this studio–and they don’t hold against me that I used to go to them 3 years ago, in order to get this price.

  2. deb
    June 18th, 2009 at 01:25 | #2

    “Honor your body”…it holds your soul, is what my first yoga teacher mentioned in her classes. When we perform the most simple movement, she would point out the magnificence of the body/mind/spirit connection. I came to yoga as an individual suffering from an absolute ego induced dance injury, and your words are profound and appreciated. blessings~deb

  3. Araun
    June 11th, 2009 at 21:37 | #3

    Thank you for your nice article and your beautyful video classes, they deliver so much calmness and integrity to the yoga practice. 15 Years ago I overloaded my body with my yoga practice. Both meniscuses are injured and I suffered from pain in the lower back. I thought, I would be listening to my body, but the ego was stronger. I had to learn to find the right dosage! I think it’s very difficult, especially if you are young, talented and ambitious. There are yoga stiles which assist to unhealthful overload as bikram yoga with it’s competitions.

  4. June 7th, 2009 at 07:46 | #4

    I run for fitness and weight loss, and yoga to stay healthy and flexible so I don’t hurt myself. I like to go slow and think about what I’m doing and be in the moment instead of rush through it and push myself too hard.

  5. Liz Waldrope
    June 4th, 2009 at 22:18 | #5

    I have a yoga mat from G2fit.com and I love it. This mat is so smart because it has the poses right on the mat. They are also eco friendly. Check them out. I think I am going to get one for my sister too.

  6. June 2nd, 2009 at 16:49 | #6

    Great article! I am a yoga teacher myself, although a novice, and this article taught me a lot. I never stress to my students to go beyond what feels comfortable. You make a lot of good points. Thanks, and I’ll keep coming back for more!

  7. lucy
    June 1st, 2009 at 10:30 | #7

    Absolutely. This is nice article..I am a yoga practioner myself and love to know more about Yoga. This article really helped me. Yoga is the most effective way to keep yourself healthy.

    Cheers!

  8. May 30th, 2009 at 00:06 | #8

    Good article, Thanks. my name Philip.

  9. May 27th, 2009 at 19:08 | #9

    I love it. Agree with you 100%. Very Clear. I will tweet it to all my peeps

  10. May 27th, 2009 at 18:46 | #10

    Hi Jesse, Your approach is exactly what I was referring to-but the more the advanced the practice is presented, the greater the challenge to take on this philosophy.

    I referenced David Svenson because he is a prime example of progressive overload with integrity. Even success elite athletes need to train with intelligence if they wish to have a long athletic career.

    I look at these deep practices with a Ying Yang concept: softness balancing out the hardness - muscles actively working, breathe and eyes calm and fluid.

    We are in a society striving for external recognition and gratification of the Ego - it is very easy for the yoga practice to satisfy these elements and shift away from a place of wellness.

    Thanks for your reply!

  11. jesse
    May 27th, 2009 at 18:21 | #11

    Kreg - very cool article. IMO, those who view yoga as purely a fitness activity are missing the much larger picture…. I find the slower I go, and the more methodical I am… the more connected I am able be with my breath and body…thus the stronger my poses become, and the longer I can hold them… and… it’s so much easier.

    Slow is fast… less is more.

    A great yoga practice to me is one that facilitates a deep connection with your mind/body.

    Almost like a bell curve, the poses at the beginning are calming and warming… in the middle when the body is loose and strong; they’re challenging… and at the end, they’re cooling and calming again.

    I find that when I approach a practice with this frame of mind from the beginning, I’m in No rush to ‘jump’ deeply into poses and my breath more naturally stays relaxed throughout. Thus facilitating a stronger, uninterrupted connection that seems to grow and grow.

    This doesn’t come from any formal training though, so I’m curious what your thoughts on this approach are.

    Keep up the awesome work building this site and community - cheers.

    Jesse

  1. No trackbacks yet.